Tension and theatrics – five takeaways from speech


Media playback is unsupported on your device

Media captionNancy Pelosi rips up a copy of the president’s speech at the end of his address.

Trump’s State of the Union speech fact-checked

It was a historic State of the Union Address – conducted the day after the Democrat’s chaotic Iowa caucuses and the day before the Senate renders its verdict in the president’s impeachment trial.

At times belligerent, at times emotional, Donald Trump delivered what will probably be his final speech to a joint session of Congress before standing for re-election in November.

Say what you will about it – about the whole evening – but it was memorable. Here are a few key takeaways.

Tensions run high

The president’s speech was bookended by two notable breaches of decorum. It began as the president handed the text of his speech to Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi, he pointedly turned away when she reached out to shake his hand.

Then, Pelosi declined to use traditional language that it was her “honour” to introduce the president.

Media playback is unsupported on your device

Media captionA State of the Union snub? Trump turns away as Pelosi goes to shake his hand.

After the conclusion of the address, Pelosi very visibly ripped up the speech text and tossed it on her desk. She would later tell a Fox News producer that it was the “courteous thing to do”, given her other options.

There were also moments during the address itself where tension boiled over. The president attacked Democratic proposals to abolish private health insurance in blunt language, saying he “would never let socialism destroy US healthcare”. He also engaged in an extended attack on Democratic-run states of New York and California for their immigration policies.

When the president spoke about gun rights, a member of the audience – the father of a child killed in the 2018 school shooting in Parkland, Florida – was removed from the chamber for shouting his objections.

Throughout the president’s speech, his lines were frequently greeted by raucous cheers from the Republican legislators, while Democrats sat in stony silence or howled in anger.

Image copyright
Mario Tama/Getty Images

Image caption

Democratic lawmakers sat in silence for much of Mr Trump’s speech – when they weren’t erupting in protest

In his speech last year, the president called for a rejection of “the politics of revenge, resistance and retribution,” touting “the boundless potential of cooperation, compromise and the common good”.

Such rhetoric was very much absent on Tuesday night, reflecting the open partisan warfare that has gripped the nation’s capital.

A re-election theme revealed

An incumbent president’s election-year State of the Union address typically foreshadows the themes of the campaign to come. If that’s the case, Donald Trump speech makes clear he’s going to bet his presidency on the state of economy.

Media playback is unsupported on your device

Media captionRepublicans chant “four more years” – the president hopes a strong economy will win him re-election.

While growth figures for the past year have been modest, the president has presided over a record-long economic expansion. At the top of his speech – the portion that will have the most Americans watching – Trump rattled through the litany of facts and figures that support his contention that times are good and will stay that way if he’s given another four years in office.

He cited deregulation, tax cuts new trade agreements as his recipe for prosperity. In the campaign to come, expect him to make the case that a Democratic change of course will hit Americans voters in the place that hurts the most – their pocketbooks.

A pitch for inclusion

At the top of his speech Donald Trump said that he was building “the world’s most prosperous and inclusive society”.

The use of the word “inclusive” wasn’t by chance. Throughout his speech, the president made repeated overtures to minority groups in America – groups that, according to polls, view the president with considerable scepticism.

Trump spoke of how he signed criminal justice reform and funded historically black colleges and universities. He specifically noted the low levels of unemployment for “African-Americans, Hispanic-Americans, and Asian-Americans”.

Among his guests at the speech were the last surviving member of the Tuskegee Airmen, the all-black World War II fighter wing group, and his great-grandson. He announced that he was awarding an “opportunity scholarship” to a young black girl to attend a private school in Philadelphia.

When talk turned to immigration, the president called out Raul Ortiz, who he recently appointed to deputy chief of Border Patrol.

Image copyright
Mario Tama/Getty Images

Image caption

Deputy Chief of US Border Patrol Raul Ortiz listens to Mr Trump’s third State of the Union address

If the president successfully improves his standing among minority voters – and convinces independent voters of all stripes that Democratic accusations of racism and xenophobia are scurrilous attacks – his path to re-election becomes considerably easier. His State of the Union address suggests that he knows this very well.

A night of theatrics

Every president since Ronald Reagan has relied on special guest recognition as a means of highlighting a policy proposal or recognising the valour or sacrifice of noteworthy individuals. Even in the most acrimonious of times, the moments give a president a chance to solicit bipartisan applause and approbation.

In Tuesday night’s speech, Trump – the inveterate showman – took things one step farther. Besides the “opportunity scholarship moment” he also paused mid-speech to have his wife award conservative radio host Rush Limbaugh with the Presidential Medal of Freedom and to surprise a military wife and her family by reuniting them with her husband, an Army sergeant who had spent the past seven months in Afghanistan.

Image copyright
MANDEL NGAN/Getty Images

Image caption

Talk show host and conservative hero Rush Limbaugh flashes a thumbs up after being recognised by the president

“We couldn’t keep him waiting any longer,” the president said, in a moment that seemed plucked from script of a daytime talk show.

Policy grab-bag

Democrat Bill Clinton used to be famous for his plan-heavy State of the Union addresses, which would bludgeon listeners with a laundry list of ideas and proposals of varying scope and prospects for success.

That’s not exactly Donald Trump’s style, but he did highlight a few priorities – none of which have much hope for success in a Congress beset by partisan gridlock.

He called more funding for vocational training in US public schools and for action to reduce the cost of prescription drugs, which prompted chants from House Democrats touting their already passed legislation that the Republican-controlled Senate has yet to take up.

Image copyright
Drew Angerer/Getty Images

When the president suggested that he was dedicated to ensuring health insurance always covers pre-existing conditions, the Democratic groans were particularly loud – a reflection of the fact that the president supports a lawsuit that would nullify the law that provides those protections.

Infrastructure spending, the white whale of bipartisan legislators for the entirety of Trump’s presidency, garnered widespread applause, as did yet another call for a US mission to the moon and Mars.

Trump also called for a law allowing the victims of crimes by undocumented immigrants to sue cities that do not cooperate with federal immigration officials and a ban on late-term abortions – both met by icy glares from the Democrats.

And that was pretty much that. If the president is going to campaign on any bold, new ideas, they’ll have to wait for another night to be unveiled.

Who will take on Trump in November?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.