A spirited turn at the mic by a first-time female MP in India’s parliament, in which she listed the “signs of early fascism”, has been hailed as the “speech of the year” on social media.
Mahua Moitra, of the opposition Trinamool Congress Party (TMC), said she had seen a list of the early warning signs of fascism on a poster in the Holocaust Memorial Museum in the US.
She said she was reading the points to show that India’s constitution was under threat and the country was being “torn apart” by the ruling party’s “lust to divide”.
Ms Moitra began by acknowledging the Bharatiya Janata Party’s landslide victory in the recent elections, but added that “the very nature of the overwhelming-ness of this mandate makes it necessary for the voices of dissent to be heard”.
Then, in a rebuke to the governing party, she listed these seven “danger signs of early fascism”:
- “There is a powerful and continuing nationalism that is searing into our national fabric,” she said. “It is superficial, it is xenophobic and it is narrow. It’s the lust to divide and not the desire to unite.”
- She pointed to a “resounding disdain for human rights“, which she said had led to a 10-fold increase in the number of hate crimes between 2014 and 2019.
- Ms Moitra criticised the government for its “unimaginable subjugation and control of mass media”. She said India’s TV channels spend “the majority of airtime broadcasting propaganda for the ruling party”.
- She attacked the government for what she said was an “obsession with national security“. An “atmosphere of fear” pervaded the country, with new enemies being created every day.
- “The government and religion are now intertwined. Do I even need to speak about this? Need I remind you that we have redefined what it means to be a citizen?” she demanded, saying laws had been amended to target Muslims.
- She said “a complete disdain for intellectuals and the arts” and “the repression of all dissent” was the most dangerous sign of all – and it was “pushing India back to the Dark Ages”.
- The last sign, Ms Moitra said, was the “erosion of independence in our electoral system“.
Ms Moitra spoke for about 10 minutes while MPs from the treasury benches tried to shout her down, but she stood firm and called on the Speaker to rein in the “professional hecklers”.
Her speech in English, which was laced with facts and figures, even included a couple of poems in Hindi. Many people on social media praised her for reciting these as she is not a Hindi-speaker – her mother tongue is Bengali.
A former investment banker with JP Morgan, Ms Moitra quit her well-paying job in London in 2009 to return to Indian politics. She has been the TMC’s national spokesperson for several years and regularly appears in prime-time TV debates.
During the recent elections, I spent two days following her around on the campaign trail in rural Krishnanagar constituency in West Bengal state, where the TMC is in power.
Read more from Geeta Pandey
In speech after speech, she took direct aim at Prime Minister Narendra Modi and his BJP. She talked about the deadly suicide attack in Kashmir and India’s subsequent air raid in Pakistan. She accused the BJP of trying to divide Hindus and Muslims. She said elections in the past were to change the government, but this election was to save the constitution of India.
So on Tuesday, when the 43-year-old stood up to address the lower house, I was expecting an intelligent speech. But it was more than that. It won her fans and admirers and trended on Twitter for hours.
Ms Moitra’s speech is significant at a time when one party – Mr Modi’s BJP – dominates parliament and the opposition is struggling to be seen and heard.
It is even more significant considering politics in India is still very patriarchal. It is dominated by men, and women make up only 14% of members of the house. And although there are some fiery female MPs, there are many who prefer to stay on the sidelines.
Ms Moitra, however, is not afraid to ruffle feathers and many will hope her speech inspires more female MPs to do the same.
“We are in the opposition, so we have to bring up the issues. We have to speak up and we have to point it out. We will speak up on whatever issues there are,” Ms Moitra told BBC Hindi on Wednesday, a day after her speech.
“The opposition’s job is to highlight the failings of the government and highlight issues that are not being dealt with by the treasury benches. That is my job and I will do that to the best of my ability.”